Texas Property Tax Appeal vs PropertyTax.io — Honest Comparison

Two different approaches to lowering your Texas property taxes. PropertyTax.io handles everything and charges 35% of your savings. We give you professional evidence for a one-time $49 and you file yourself. Here is how to decide.

TL;DR

PropertyTax.io takes a managed approach — they handle everything and charge 35% of your savings. We give you professional-quality evidence for a $49 flat fee and you file yourself. The tradeoff is convenience vs keeping 100% of your reduction. On $1,100 savings over 3 years: $49 total with us vs $1,155 with PropertyTax.io.

Side-by-Side Comparison

BEST VALUE

Texas Property Tax Appeal

Pricing$49 flat fee
On $1,100 savingsYou keep $1,021
Who does workYou, with evidence
Filing supportTX-specific guide
Guarantee7-day refund
DataReal CAD values
Coverage30 TX counties

PropertyTax.io

Pricing35% of savings
On $1,100 savingsYou keep $715
Who does workThey handle it
Filing supportThey file for you
GuaranteeNo fee if no savings
DataProfessional analysis
CoverageMultiple TX counties

The Math Over 3 Years

Assuming $1,100 in annual tax savings, here is what you actually keep over three years with each approach:

Texas Property Tax Appeal

Year 1 cost$49
Year 2 cost$0
Year 3 cost$0
Total cost$49
Total savings kept$3,221

PropertyTax.io

Year 1 cost$385 (35% of $1,100)
Year 2 cost$385 (35% of $1,100)
Year 3 cost$385 (35% of $1,100)
Total cost$1,155
Total savings kept$2,145

Over 3 years, the flat-fee approach saves you $1,076 more than the percentage-based model — assuming the same reduction each year.

When PropertyTax.io Makes Sense

PropertyTax.io’s managed approach works well in certain scenarios:

When We Make Sense

Our flat-fee model is built for homeowners who want to keep every dollar of their reduction:

The Honest Bottom Line

Both approaches are better than doing nothing. The real question is whether you want to trade 35% of your savings for someone else managing the process.

If you are willing to spend 30–60 minutes filing a protest with professional-quality evidence, you keep over $1,000 more over three years with our flat-fee approach. If you genuinely want a managed experience with live consultant access and are okay with the 35% fee, PropertyTax.io removes the effort entirely. Either way, you are reducing your property taxes — and that is the most important part.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does PropertyTax.io charge?

PropertyTax.io charges 35% of whatever tax savings they achieve on your behalf. There is no upfront fee — you only pay if they successfully reduce your property taxes. On $1,100 in savings, that works out to $385 per year.

Is PropertyTax.io worth the 35% fee?

PropertyTax.io provides a fully managed service with live consultant access, which saves significant time and effort. However, the 35% fee compounds over multiple years. On $1,100 annual savings over 3 years, you pay $1,155 to PropertyTax.io versus $49 one-time with our DIY approach. Whether that convenience is worth $1,076 over three years depends on how you value your time.

What is the difference between PropertyTax.io and Texas Property Tax Appeal?

PropertyTax.io is a full managed service — they handle evidence, filing, and hearings, charging 35% of savings. We provide professional-quality evidence packets for a one-time $49 flat fee and you handle the filing yourself with our step-by-step guide. The tradeoff is convenience versus keeping 100% of your reduction.

Can I file my own protest instead of using PropertyTax.io?

Yes. Filing a property tax protest in Texas is a straightforward process that most homeowners can handle themselves. Our evidence packet, filing guide, and hearing walkthrough give you everything you need for a one-time $49 fee — and you keep 100% of any reduction you achieve.

Check Your Assessment Free

Enter your address to see how your home’s assessed value compares to similar properties in your neighborhood. Takes 30 seconds.

Check My Assessment Free