Sunrise Cay & Island Cay area, San Antonio 78251

CAD Neighborhood 99651

Property tax protest data for the Sunrise Cay & Island Cay area, San Antonio 78251 (Neighborhood 99651) in Bexar County. 44 homes, $158/sqft median.

Strong protest signal
99% success rate · 44 homes analyzed
What protesters saved
$16,936
County-wide avg. per successful protest (2024)
Protest success rate
99%
Based on 185,673 county-wide protests (2024)
Homes analyzed
44
Median assessment
$158/sqft
Avg: $162/sqft

Source: BCAD public records, 2024 protest season

What this means for your property

44 homes in this area were assessed at a median $158/sqft. With a 99% protest success rate, most homeowners who challenged their assessment received a reduction. If your home is assessed higher than comparable properties, you likely have grounds to protest. An evidence packet shows exactly how your assessment compares — with the specific comps and data you'd present at a hearing.

What's in the evidence packet?

5 comparable properties matched to your home, an assessment gap analysis showing where your value exceeds comps, a filing checklist for BCAD, and a hearing script you can read at your informal hearing.

How does the protest process work?

You file a protest with BCAD (online via BCAD Online Portal), attend an informal hearing where you present your evidence, and most cases settle right there. The evidence packet gives you everything you need for that hearing.

What's the deadline?

The protest deadline for Bexar County is May 15. You must file before this date to protest your 2026 assessment.

Check your property

See how your home compares to 44 others in Sunrise Cay & Island Cay area, San Antonio 78251

$49 flat fee · No recurring fees — you keep 100% · 7-day money-back guarantee

📅 Deadline: May 15, 2026 (28 days left) Full refund if unused 🔒 Secure checkout 🛡 No risk — filing can’t raise your taxes

What's in your evidence packet

5 comparable properties matched to your home
Assessment gap analysis with dollar amounts
Bexar County filing checklist
Hearing script you can read word-for-word
Comparable sales grid (PDF)
Step-by-step BCAD Online Portal walkthrough
In Bexar County, 185,673 property owners protested last year. 99% received a reduction.

Compare similar neighborhoods in Bexar County

Neighborhood Homes Median $/Sq Ft Win Rate
Toulouse & John Barrett Dr area, San Antonio 78240 148 $158 same
Ash Field Dr & Beacon Fld area, San Antonio 78245 578 $158 same
Silent Sunset & Silent Spg area, San Antonio 78250 355 $158 same
Big Spring Ln & Lateleaf Oak area, San Antonio 78223 390 $158 same
Segovia Way & Camp Real Ln area, San Antonio 78253 442 $158 same

Neighborhoods with the closest median $/sq ft to Sunrise Cay & Island Cay area, San Antonio 78251.

Top flagged properties in Sunrise Cay & Island Cay area, San Antonio 78251

Address % Above $/Sqft Est. Savings
2107 ISLAND CAY 21% $191 $1,014
7807 SUNRISE CAY 20% $189 $975
7818 SUNRISE CAY 20% $189 $975
7727 SUNRISE CAY 19% $188 $955
7718 SUNRISE CAY 19% $188 $955

Properties assessed highest above the neighborhood median.